Bildtext får vara max två rader text. Hela texten ska högerjusteras om den bara ska innehålla fotobyline! Photo: B. Christensen/Azote
Time for a new toolkit in sustainable fisheries
A stringent focus on seafood certification neglects the diversity of tools needed to create sustainable fishing practices and conservation
- Sustainable seafood certification helps encourage sustainable fishing practices but is often ineffective and masks the need for a more diverse range of tools.
- Researchers suggest ways of creating stronger connections between local producers and consumers along with involving fisheries in formal management.
- To enhance sustainability within fisheries, building local ties of trust is needed
The American psycologist Abraham Maslow once said: “If the only tool you have is a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail.” In modern seafood production, certification is considered the metaphorical hammer and the one-size-fits-all solution to everything.
Led by Joshua S. Stoll from the University of Maine together with centre researcher Malin Jonell and Megan Bailey from the Life Sciences Centre in Nova Scotia, the authors argue that a stringent focus on seafood certification neglects the diversity of tools needed to create sustainable fishing practices and conservation.
Certifications are becoming a contemporary hammer in the marine conservation and stewardship toolbox.
Joshua S. Stoll, lead author
Simple in theory, a struggle in practice
Seafood certifications encourage a standard of sustainability by offering economic incentives to fisheries who follow sustainable practices. This branches off into programmes such as Fisheries Improvement Projects (FIP) for fisheries that aim for certification.
But Stoll and his co-authors argue that certification may not be so effective in practice. There is often a mismatch between the demand for eco-friendly seafood and the actual behaviour of consumers faced with higher prices. It also leaves non-certified small-scale and data poor fisheries behind, which limits the supply of eco-labelled seafood on the market.
The researchers point out main issues with this practice, stating that “these fixes are illustrative of a deepening investment in a single tool that has not been wholly effective at achieving socioeconomic and environmental sustainability and faces persistent challenges.”
Restoring relations, expanding solutions
The authors emphasise the need to work with a new toolkit to tackle problems within small-scale fisheries. They suggest the role of relational seafood supply chains in achieving sustainable fishing, which focus on building stronger relations between local fisheries and consumers.
To do so, they highlight three central ways enhancing local relations could strengthen sustainability within fisheries:
Financing adaptive capacity - Suggests a way for fishers to generate a higher revenue for their harvests. This occurs because of a smaller divide between seafood producers and consumers along with ties of trust that form between them. This also helps to preserve livelihoods such as salmon producers Alaskans Own strengthening connections between local consumers and producers while using extra earnings to support local conservation projects.
Facilitating production of social capital – The value of exchanges between people and groups is key to building connections and taking action around a shared goal of sustainable fishing. An example of this exists in North Carolina, USA, where connections of trust between producers and consumers lead to transparency about the quality of seafood being sourced.
Catalyzing Agency - The last contribution involves ways of supporting small-scale fisheries by including their voices in policy changes. For example, a few fishery founders in North America have been represented in fisheries management.
Ultimately, the researchers suggest that relational seafood supply chains might offer the above solutions, although they are “no more a guarantee of sustainability than are seafood certifications.”
What they can provide, however, is to put the ingenuity and problem‐solving capacity of fishers and coastal communities at the forefront of the discussion.
Research news | 2022-06-23
What's at stake at the UN Ocean Conference?
We asked some of our experts why all eyes are turned to the UN Ocean Conference in Lisbon
Research news | 2022-06-23
Where to find us at the UN Ocean Conference
Where and when to find us during the UN Ocean Conference in Lisbon, Portugal 27 June - 1 July
Research news | 2022-06-21
Ocean research lacks female leaders
In senior academic positions women are still struggling to break the glass ceiling, new study shows
Research news | 2022-06-20
Malin Jonell awarded for novel approaches to Baltic Sea research
Centre researcher Malin Jonell has won the Östersjöakuten award 2022 for her research contributions to the Baltic Sea
Research news | 2022-06-17
Concerns over intensive brackish-water aquaculture in eastern India
Rapid expansion of brackish-water shrimp farming may have severe long-term socioeconomic consequences, new study warns
Research news | 2022-06-17
For the sake of sustainability, norms and incentives must change
New study identifies the five best places to intervene in a system to trigger transformations