SUSTAINABLE FOOD PRODUCTION
The effects of less, but better meat production
Study captures the real-world experiences and effects of a farm’s journey towards sustainability
- On-farm commitment to sustainability and implementing more agro-ecological practices can improve sustainability overall, including reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 70%
- Reducing the number of animals on the farm was key for a range of sustainability improvements, including reducing total land use
- To realise the full sustainability gains, commitment from value-chain actors and policy is key
WE CHANGED A FARM: Going from intensive beef and crop production to organic, agroecological farming can boost labour productivity and safeguard the environment but may also hit finances hard, at least in a transition period.
This is the conclusion from a case study published in Agronomy for Sustainable Development.
Centre PhD student Kajsa Resare Sahlin analysed with colleagues from Sweden and Germany a farm in east-central Sweden committed to a more sustainable business model. They got an insight into the pains and perks of going through such a transition.
This study captures the real-world experiences and effects of a journey towards sustainability.
Kajsa Resare Sahlin, lead author
Improvements and downsizing
Between 2017 and 2020, substantial changes took place at all levels of the farm.
It went from running a farm of 1200 bulls (completely housed indoors) and a cropping system relying heavily on fertilizers and chemical pesticides, to a business with only 350 heifers primarily grazing outdoors and a crop production increasingly based on organic fertilizers.
The researchers used the SMART-Farm tool which is considered to be among the most complete sustainability assessment tools available.
The assessment revealed an overall improvement in the sustainability performance of the farm. CO2 emissions was reduced with almost 70% and had positive effects on biodiversity.
Work environment and health risks also improved while animal welfare increased thanks to better indoor conditions and access to grazing for all ruminants.
Impact on local economy
But the transition had a significant impact on the farming business which was downsized by more than half. In particular, the downscaled beef production had a substantial impact on the net farm income.
It also had a negative effect on the local economy because the farm bought less from local and national sellers and reduced its work opportunities for people in the area - the number of full-time workers went from 14 to less than seven.
The transition however resulted in more value per worker, boosting labour productivity, and despite fewer job opportunities, those available are safer and more viable for the long term.
Despite the reduced overall economic activity, the number of buyers of the farm’s products doubled from pre-transition times and the farm is looking to establish more equal and long-term buyer-seller relations.
Not full potential
But the farm has still not yet fully realised the potential sustainability gains from the agroecological transition, and as many other farmers, it’s a struggle to make the business financially viable. That, according to the authors, is hard, because how the farm operates must be seen in a bigger context.
“It is beyond the control of the individual farm to fully realize its sustainability potential. What value-chain actors and policy makers do is also crucial,” they conclude.
Resare Sahlin, K., Carolus, J., von Greyerz, K. et al. 2022. Delivering “less but better” meat in practice—a case study of a farm in agroecological transition. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 42, 24. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13593-021-00737-5
News & events
Research news | 2024-02-20
Having good neighbours and few top predators make predatory fish populations more resilient
A regime shift is gradually spreading through the archipelagos of the Swedish Baltic Sea coast, where shallow bays, previously dominated by pike and perch have one by one become dominated by one of their prey species, the three-spined stickleback.
Research news | 2024-02-08
Eating new plant-based foods can be good for the environment, your health and your economy
Replacing animal-source foods with plant-based alternatives or whole foods decreases environmental impact, meets nutrition recommendations, and can be cost-competitive with the current average Swedish diet
Research news | 2024-01-29
Bird AI and sailing drones – green game changers for marine ecosystems
Groups of guillemots on an island in the Baltic Sea have unknowingly inspired how marine research can be done. Two AI-powered research projects can change how to monitor marine ecosystems – and potentially manage them in real-time
Research news | 2024-01-24
Centralised social networks can hinder innovation by making decision-making too similar
Social systems where influence is centred around one or two individuals can lead to pack mentality and groupthink in farming communities
Research news | 2024-01-23
Planetary Commons: Fostering global cooperation to safeguard critical Earth system functions
We should look at tipping elements of the Earth system as global commons, argue researchers in a new paper published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Research news | 2024-01-22
Soy: A world journey from success to uncertainty
From a bean valued for its multitude of functions in ancient China to one of the most traded agricultural commodities of the modern world: the soybean has gone through dramatic changes throughout the millennia.