What it takes to address several challenges at the same time
Four insights into dealing with environmental policy issue interdependencies
- To effectively resolve complex environmental problems, the capacity to address several different challenges in concert must be improved
- Study suggests a new methodological procedure to enable decision-making that acknowledges how environmental challenges influence each other
- Four insights emerged when applying the procedure to a case of water governance in Mideast Sweden
ONE THING CAN LEAD TO ANOTHER: If you want to reduce water pollution from agriculture you could develop rules against ditching in order to decrease nutrient and pesticide runoff from fields. An added bonus to such measure is that reducing ditching can also prevent the loss of crucial wetlands.
Welcome to the world of “policy issue interdependency”, when a policy addressing one environmental issue can have consequences for another, creating win-wins or trade-offs.
Policy issue interdependencies are rarely explicitly defined nor assessed close to the everyday practices of policy actors.
Johanna Hedlund, first author
Together with centre colleague Örjan Bodin and Daniel Nohrstedt from Uppsala University, Hedlund has developed a new methodological procedure for dealing with policy issue interdependencies, which they have tested on a case study of water governance in the Norrström drainage basin, located in Mideast Sweden.
The study was published in the International Journal of the Commons.
“Acknowledging how policy issues influence each other can improve our capacity to address complex environmental problems and make interventions more effective,” adds Örjan Bodin.
Many previous studies have pinpointed the importance of such interdependencies, but provided scant guidance for local and regional decision makers who must face them without being overwhelmed by ‘uncertainty paralysis’.
The study’s focus on the Norrström drainage basin was motivated by its national importance and many interconnected water bodies giving rise to a range of policy issues and interdependencies.
The basin includes the capital of Stockholm and is governed by one public organisation. It encapsulates the big lakes Mälaren and Hjälmaren as well as 62 municipalities populated by approximately 20% of the Swedish population.
Applying the new methodological procedure to the Norrström drainage basin resulted in four major insights:
- Policy actors confirmed that the procedure is reliable
- Many, but certainly not all, policy issues were found to be interdependent
- Policy issue interdependencies are most important to pay attention to when the overall level of interdependency is moderate
- The study also spurred new research questions about how actors perceive policy issue interdependencies, in particular if it is easier to comprehend and act on reinforcing (win-win) or counteracting (trade-off) interdependencies.
“Policy issue interdependencies do not exist in one form only, they vary by degree and type of interdependency. Detailing this diversity can reveal where policy intervention is potentially most effective,” Johanna Hedlund concludes.
The study combined and built on several previous methodologies, tools and frameworks, in particular network methods combined with the “Open Standards for the Practice of Conservation, OS” and its associated Miradi Open Standards software. The two have been used in more than hundred conservation projects globally and can unravel how actors organise actions to achieve certain targets by explicitly mapping causes and effects. Mapping this is useful for identifying actions that are associated with two or more policy issues, and thereby making them interdependent.
Hedlund, J., Bodin, Ö. and Nohrstedt, D., 2021. Assessing Policy Issue Interdependencies in Environmental Governance. International Journal of the Commons, 15(1), pp.82–99. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/ijc.1060
Research news | 2022-08-17
Örjan Bodin new professor in Environmental Sciences
Appointment adds to an increasing list of centre researchers being acknowledged for their work
Research news | 2022-08-12
What it takes to make different approaches work together
Researchers invite readers “behind the scenes” to share their experiences combining agent-based modelling and controlled behavioural experiments
Research news | 2022-08-11
Adding the technological to the social-ecological
Researchers make the case for a more systematic way of thinking when designing urban, nature-based solutions
Research news | 2022-08-05
Not only clear-cuts, but even forest degradation drives CO2 emissions
Further degradation of the Amazon rainforest can lead to enormous C02 emissions in the upcoming decades, unless it is halted soon, new study finds
Research news | 2022-08-04
Growing tree cover can boost or dwindle water availability
Tree restoration is a great way to mitigate climate change and store atmospheric carbon. But when trees are planted at a large scale, regional water availability can be seriously affected
Research news | 2022-07-05
New exhibition at Skansen open-air museum features inputs from centre
Last week, Skansen, an open-air museum in Stockholm, launched the first part of an exhibition about biodiversity with contributions by the Stockholm Resilience Centre