Why small-scale fisheries pursue different ways to survive
Better understanding of diversification strategies could improve policies for the many millions of people who depend on small-scale fisheries
- New study focuses on diversification strategies of small-scale fisheries across the state of Baja California Sur in Mexico
- A social-ecological network approach was applied to analyse fisheries landings data between 2008–2016
- The results constitute an important step towards understanding and managing the complex environmental changes affecting small-scale fisheries
TO SURVIVE, DIVERSIFY: What do you do when both your catch and livelihood are in peril? This is something that many people depending on fishing around the world are struggling with as they try to adapt to changes imposed by global warming, degrading ecosystems and increasingly globalized markets.
Not surprisingly, some of the most common strategies include targeting diverse species, moving to fish elsewhere (temporarily or permanently) or pursuing alternative livelihoods.
But we still have too little detailed information about small-scale fisheries diversification strategies, especially in low- and middle-income countries, according to a new study published in the journal Environmental Science and Policy.
There is a growing need to better understand how such diversification strategies are influenced by institutional, economic and environmental factors for the many millions of people who depend on these fisheries.
Blanca Gonzalez-Mon, lead author
The study also includes centre colleagues Örjan Bodin, Emilie Lindkvist and Maja Schlüter, as well as researchers from Stanford University, University of California Santa Cruz and Duke University, members of the MAREA research group.
Two main questions
The new study focuses on the small-scale fisheries across the state of Baja California Sur in Mexico, addressing two specific questions:
- How do patterns of species and spatial diversification change over time?
- What environmental and institutional factors influence the observed diversification patterns?
To find the answers the researchers adopted a so called social-ecological network approach to analyse a fisheries landings data with a high level of resolution from 2008–2016. For example, whereas some patterns of diversification between different landing regions can occur annually, others can change dramatically across years. This means that the same actor can be fishing in two distant regions during the same year.
In combination with a qualitative analysis of existing literature this enabled the authors to illuminate potential underlying environmental and other factors that could be influencing the observed diversification strategies.
More than just El Niño
The results indicate that changes in the diversification between regions are correlated with regional oceanographic changes, like the weather phenomenon El Niño which brings unusually warm sea surface temperatures and lower primary productivity every two to seven years.
Events like these are known to trigger significant changes in the distribution and abundance of fish and other marine resources.
Rather than acting in isolation, the authors hypothesize that environmental drivers like El Niño operate in combination with the local social, economic and institutional context to mediate diversification of fisheries strategies.
Overall, the results highlight that “spatial diversification” (when people move to follow a target species, or move to fish other species) is a highly dynamic and diverse process.
This improved understanding of diversification strategies constitutes an important step towards fisheries policies that account for the complex mechanisms through which environmental changes affect small-scale fisheries around the world.
The researchers use a network approach to analyze patterns of spatial and local diversification. This approach measures the network connectivity, which here implies there are economic units that deploy diversification strategies, either locally (species diversification within a region) or spatially (diversification across regions).
This approach required delineating landing regions to define spatial diversification and the synthesis of the fisheries landings database.
To interpret observed patterns of spatial diversification, the researchers identify drivers of change based on published information and qualitative data.
Gonzalez-Mon, B., Bodin, Ö., Lindkvist, E., Frawley, T.H. et.al. 2021. Spatial diversification as a mechanism to adapt to environmental changes in small-scale fisheries. Environmental Science & Policy Volume 116, February 2021, Pages 246-257. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2020.11.006
Research news | 2023-01-19
Time for an "IPCC for the ocean"
Leading ocean experts propose a new International Panel for Ocean Sustainability (IPOS) to build consensus and inform policy
Research news | 2023-01-13
Going beyond dichotomies of local versus global food systems
Food systems are becoming increasingly stressed, but whether they are local or global is not the big issue
Research news | 2022-12-22
Overshooting climate targets could significantly increase risk for tipping cascades
Temporarily overshooting the climate targets of 1.5-2 degrees Celsius could increase the tipping risk of several Earth system elements by more than 70 per cent, a new risk analysis study shows
Research news | 2022-12-22
Human rights gain recognition in new biodiversity framework
The new Global Biodiversity Framework adopted at COP15 takes the important step of recognising the rights of Indigenous peoples, local communities, women and youth
General news | 2022-12-22
Beatrice Crona and Magnus Nyström appointed as new science directors
Shifts in the scientific leadership of SRC in the new year
Research news | 2022-12-20
Biodiversity offsets create dangerous incentives
Biodiversity offset schemes may shift the focus from the actual drivers of biodiversity loss and require more, not less, regulations, argue researchers