Sustainability claims behind booming food technologies lack evidence
Money is pouring into food tech. But despite rosy claims, food innovations are rarely empirically assessed from a broader sustainability perspective.
- The sustainability claims of food innovation technologies lack evidence
- Vertical farming, blockchain, food deliveries and plant-based foods have varying sustainability performances
- A new sustainability assessment framework is neeeded to guide investments
“Food system technologies are often surrounded by a sustainability halo. And many of them strive to reduce climate impact, but they disregard other dimensions of sustainability,” says Anne Charlotte Bunge, researcher at the Stockholm Resilience Centre at Stockholm University and lead author of a recent study published in Nature Food.
In the study, the research team compared the scientific evidence behind sustainability claims of four food system technologies: plant-based substitutes for meat, dairy, eggs or sea food; vertical farming; food deliveries; and blockchain technology.
All four receive considerable interest from venture capital firms across Scandinavia, and all are frequently framed as new sustainable solutions.
However, the scientific evidence to back these claims up is limited, according to the new study.
Food system technologies are often surrounded by a sustainability halo. And many of them strive to reduce climate impact, but they disregard other dimensions of sustainability.
Anne Charlotte Bunge, centre researcher
For blockchain technology, no research has shown any tangible sustainability improvements related to its usage in the food industry. Studies that have been published so far only discussed theoretical benefits.
Plant-based substitutes are found to have lower environmental impacts than conventional animal-based products. But research on their nutritional aspects has not been studied over the long term, and other socioeconomic factors, such as pricing, are rarely discussed.
“Plant-based alternatives are higher in costs than conventional animal products, which could generate the impression that a plant-based diet is more expensive and seen as a luxury, leading to social inequalities,” warns lead author Anne Charlotte Bunge.
Vertical farming has a mixed sustainability performance. Vertical farms outperform on-field cultivation and greenhouses in some aspects, such as land and water use. However, they often require more energy and emit more greenhouse gases than field agriculture. And regarding other aspects of sustainability, there is little research: “We found a distinct lack of evidence modelling the socio-economic implications of scaling vertical farming,” says Anne Charlotte Bunge.
Food deliveries performed worse in most aspects of sustainability, except that delivered groceries are better than making individual trips to the supermarket by car – but not by foot or public transport. Having meals delivered to one’s home did not have any benefits, according to the analysis.
“Research demonstrates that walking to the restaurant and consuming the meal there instead of having it delivered could reduce the total amount of greenhouse gas emissions by 68 % per meal,” says Anne Charlotte Bunge.
Even here, significant gaps in research exist on other environmental issues and social sustainability.
To prevent misled investments in the future, the researchers call for a new sustainability assessment framework.
“Guiding transformative investments requires a more rigorous, quantitative assessment of the sustainability implications of food system technologies,” says co-author Line Gordon, professor researcher at the Stockholm Resilience Centre at Stockholm University.
Read A systematic scoping review of the sustainability of vertical farming, plant-based alternatives, food delivery services and blockchain in food systems
What are the four food technologies?
Plant-based alternatives: Vegan substitutes of meat, dairy, seafood, and eggs, that mimic the structure, taste, and sensory profile of conventional animal-based products.
Vertical farming: Multi-layer vertical indoor crop production systems with controlled growth conditions and without solar light.
Blockchain technology: A decentralized distributed ledger technology that traces the supply chain to create transparency.
Food deliveries: The delivery of meals and groceries that have been purchased online by various means of transport. Part of the wider digital food environment.
Bunge, A.C., Wood, A., Halloran, A., Gordon, L.J. 2022. A systematic scoping review of the sustainability of vertical farming, plant-based alternatives, food delivery services and blockchain in food systems. Nature Food.
Research news | 2022-11-25
Successes and shortfalls: reflections on COP27
In the wake of COP27, we gather reflections from centre staff who were involved on the ground.
Research news | 2022-11-25
Access to greenery and water goes hand in hand with human wellbeing during the pandemic
Green wedges and large nature areas are especially important for the young, elderly and unemployed, a new comparative study finds.
Research news | 2022-11-22
Fair access to water is a subjective issue in post-drought Cape Town
Who should pay for and benefit from water services? It depends on who you ask, finds a study that revisited Cape Town after its 2015-2018 water crisis
General news | 2022-11-15
Centre researchers listed among the world's most influential scientists
Carl Folke, Johan Rockström, Thomas Elmqvist, Per Olsson, Max Troell and Jonathan Donges ranked as some of the globally most cited researchers
Research news | 2022-11-14
In data scarce regions, fieldwork and historical images help researchers fill in the gaps
Researchers combined current data with historical images and inputs from previous studies to estimate how ecosystem services have changed over time in northern Burkina Faso
Research news | 2022-11-10
Fair global redistribution of resources is key for planetary stability
Redistributing resources and transforming society are necessary to ensure universal access to basic needs while staying within Earth’s limits