Getting a more complete picture of our impact on nature
New metric can help investors, companies, cities, and governments track their environmental impacts beyond greenhouse gas emissions
- Researchers hope their new metric prototype will catalyse further scientific work as well as action by investors, companies, cities, and governments
- Sub-global interactions between planetary boundaries were assessed, e.g. how deforestation in one country can amplify climate impacts elsewhere
- The largest amplification factor measured was a more than doubling of Earth system impacts from deforesting Amazon rainforest
NOT UP TO THE TASK: The Environmental, Social and Governance metrics are a set of standards designed to assess the impact an investment might have on the environment. Centre researchers have previously criticised the use of the metrics for being inadequate.
In a study published in Environmental Research Letters, other colleagues draw similar conclusions:
“Developing a new metric for assessing the systemic impacts of businesses, investors and other actors on the Earth system is extremely important, since the current standards are not up to the task,” says centre researcher Steve Lade, first author of the new study.
Planetary interactions at smaller scales
In the new study, Lade and his colleagues suggest a way to better understand the environmental impacts of corporate and public entities.
The starting point of the study is the planetary boundary framework and its 'safe' global limits of human pressures on the Earth system—the planet’s climate and ecosystems.
However, in order to enable companies, cities and other actors to assess the impacts of their decisions, it is important to understand how planetary boundaries interact at smaller scales.
One example is how deforestation in tropical Africa can trigger other impacts on climate, land and water elsewhere. Therefore, Lade and his colleagues started by tailoring their new metric around sub-global interactions between three processes: climate change, vegetation cover and surface water runoff.
One of the most interesting results, according to the authors, was that the Earth system impact of deforesting the Amazon rainforest was amplified by a massive 2.5 times according to the new metric.
A first step and a word of caution
The resulting prototype metric can help stakeholders track their environmental impacts beyond greenhouse gas emissions.
Moreover, it is a first step towards a way to account for key interactions among multiple Earth system processes, something that has so far been completely missing in all major corporate impact and risk assessment frameworks.
For example, the fact that the new metric resulted in 0 for Australian tropical forests only communicates that incremental loss of these forests would not currently have global scale impacts on climate, land cover or water.
The local effects on rare or threatened species might, however, be severe.
The approach consisted of two main steps using the spatially-resolved dynamical global vegetation model LPJmL (Schaphoff et al 2018 to estimate the strengths of cross-scale interactions between climate, land and water; and using these interaction strengths in a simple feedback model to calculate measures that assess the consequences of these interactions for the Earth system, specifically an amplification factor and an Earth system impact metric.
Detailed descriptions of the calculations are available here
The authors use the terms 'pressure' and 'state' in line with the (drivers, pressures, states, impacts, responses) framework and reserve the term 'impact' for the cumulative change in state once all feedbacks, themselves triggered by an initial change in state, have played out.
Lade, S.J., Fetzer, I., Cornell, S.E., Crona, B. 2021. A prototype Earth system impact metric that accounts for cross-scale interactions. Environ. Res. Lett. 16 115005.
News & events
Research news | 2023-06-02
More freshwater experts needed in the IPBES biodiversity panel
Centre researcher Jan Kuiper lists why and how more freshwater experts could contribute to the Intergovernmental Science–Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services
General news | 2023-06-01
Centre researcher Juan Rocha elected into Young Academy of Sweden
Centre researcher Juan Rocha joins the Young Academy of Sweden, a junior version of the prestigious Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, for a five-year term
Research news | 2023-05-31
Groundbreaking study quantifies safe and just Earth system boundaries
International commission proposes new safe and just boundaries for maintaining a healthy planet and protecting people from significant harm
Research news | 2023-05-25
AI could create a perfect storm of climate misinformation
The speed and the way misinformation about climate change and sustainability issues moves around the world is rapidly changing. Now, the Centre presents a new synthesis on AI and climate misinformation in connection to the Nobel Prize Summit 2023, "Truth, Trust and Hope"
Research news | 2023-05-22
Financial actors and academia join forces to build back biodiversity
Today is International Biodiversity Day! This year with the theme “From agreement to action: build back biodiversity”, and for us, that is a good reason to highlight the potential of the finance sector in reviving biodiversity
General news | 2023-05-17
Maria Tengö appointed special professor at Wageningen University
Maria Tengö is the most recently appointed professor at the Stockholm Resilience Centre