Increased use of AI can create new sustainability risks
Research identifies four areas where the use of AI-technologies can create challenges for both people and planet
- The most rapid development of AI-technologies in the sustainability domain is happening in farming, in particular in China and the USA
- Identified risks include algorithmic bias, unequal access, cascading failures and trade-offs between efficiency and resilience
- The study is the result of two international workshops and an initiative coordinated by the centre, the Beijer Institute of Ecological Economics and Princeton University
NOT ALWAYS OK, COMPUTER: The growing use of AI-technologies offers opportunities for ramped up sustainability efforts, but there are also numerous poorly explored and serious systemic risks as humans, machines and ecosystems interact in new ways.
This is the main message from a new study looking into the global uptake of AI-technologies in farming, forestry and the marine sector.
While applications of AI could lead to more effective uses of land- and seascapes, improved environmental monitoring, and increased transparency in supply chains, it could also create a number of new emerging risks for both people and nature.
Victor Galaz, first author, deputy director of the Stockholm Resilience Centre
Rapid development in farming
The study is the result of a collaboration between the centre, the Beijer Institute and Princeton Institute for International and Regional Studies. Two workshops in 2019 gathered a number of experts and formed the basis for the study.
Authors include researchers from Cornell University, CGIAR Platform for Big Data in Agriculture, Graz University of Technology, and University College London.
The study, which is published in the journal Technology in Society, also presents new data about where in the world AI-technologies for sustainability is diffusing.
“Our analysis shows that the most rapid development is unfolding in farming, with substantial investments in these technologies in China and the United States in particular,” says Galaz.
Need to address gap
Artificial intelligence in combination with sensor technology and robotics are increasingly being applied in agriculture, forestry and marine resources extraction.
In these sectors with high impact potential for sustainability, the study explores emerging systemic risks in four areas:
1) Algorithmic bias and allocative harms
For example, the training data and the resulting model may be developed and suitable for a large industrial farm in a data rich context, while using it as decision-support for a small-scale farm in a low-income country could lead to flawed and damaging results.
2) Unequal access and benefits
Due to the global “digital divide” small-scale farmers in less wealthy countries often face serious obstacles to access big data and mobile technologies, which is likely to distribute the benefits of AI-technologies in unequal ways.
3) Cascading failures and external disruptions
One example is how “Virtual farms,” using AI and big data from sensors, often require cloud storage, susceptible to breaches. Earlier this year, this risk was manifested in cyberattacks forcing the shutdown of numerous meat plants in the U.S.
4) Trade-offs between efficiency and resilience
Using AI-technologies to increase efficiency and productivity of a particular crop, tree or seafood species, risks undermining overall system functioning and resilience. This has proven to cause abrupt, unwanted, and sometimes irreversible changes in ecosystems.
The article also concludes that current interest in principles for “responsible AI” could do much more to integrate environmental sustainability dimensions. Most emphasis so far has been on social aspects.
“If we are serious about using AI for sustainability, this is a gap that needs to be addressed urgently,” says Victor Galaz.
Link to publication
Watch video on the sustainability opportunities and challenges with AI and new technology:
Galaz, V., Centeno, M.A., Callahan, P.W., Causevic, A., Patterson, T. et.al. 2021. Artificial intelligence, systemic risks, and sustainability. Technology in Society Volume 67, November 2021, 101741, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2021.101741
News & events
Stockholm seminars | 2023-10-11
How relationships contribute to and can help solve grand sustainability challenges
Michele Barnes, James Cook University, uncovers how relationships can mediate the drivers and outcomes of sustainability challenges
General news | 2023-09-19
New Google.org grant funds Centre research on AI-powered climate risk tool
Google.org has awarded five million US dollars to a group of scientists, including Centre researchers, to develop and scale ClimateIQ , an artificial intelligence-powered climate risk evaluation tool for cities
General news | 2023-09-19
Researchers and chefs team up for a sustainable lunch week
“Risotto on Swedish oat-rice, with apple cider vinegar, blue mussels from Bohuslän, parsley, and grated Svecia cheese”. That’s one of the science-cooked dishes that guests can enjoy at “A Planetary Lunch” — an experimental lunch week at Stockholm university
Research news | 2023-09-14
The SDGs are not on track — new report outlines what needs to happen
Humanity is set to miss the Sustainable Development Goals. But decisive and timely policy actions can kickstart extraordinary turnarounds and a giant leap toward achieving the SDGs
Research news | 2023-09-13
All planetary boundaries mapped out for the first time, six of nine crossed
For the first time, an international team of scientists is able to provide a detailed outline of planetary resilience by mapping out all nine boundary processes that define a safe operating space for humanity.
General news | 2023-09-04
Centre secures 28 MSEK research funding in two new Formas grants
The two grants worth 14 million SEK each will focus on the intersection of climate, water and biodiversity