A better understanding of how tipping points work
Why the polar ice sheets are of particular importance for the stability of the climate system as a whole
- With progressing global warming, there is increased risk that climate system tipping elements cross a critical threshold
- Study shows that this risk increases significantly when considering interactions between tipping elements: domino-like interactions foster cascading, nonlinear responses
- The negative feedback loop connecting the Greenland Ice Sheet and the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation might not be able to stabilise the climate system as a whole
A DOMINO EFFECT? Over the past decades, significant changes have been observed in several climate system tipping elements, including the ice sheets of Greenland and West Antarctica, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) and the Amazon rainforest.
With global warming continuing, there is increased risk that these tipping elements might cross a critical threshold, resulting in severe consequences for the global climate, ecosystems and human societies.
Triggering domino effects
For example, it is thought that the Amazon rainforest is close to a critical level of deforestation which might, together with global warming, initiate such a transition, putting 30–50% of rainforest ecosystems at risk of shifting to tropical savannah or dry forests.
But while the processes underlying these shifts are fairly well understood, it is unclear how their interactions might impact the overall stability of the Earth’s climate system.
A new paper in Earth System Dynamics led by Nico Wunderling from the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, with centre researcher Jonathan Donges, analyses the risk of domino effects being triggered by each individual tipping elements due to global warming.
This analysis presents a first step towards synthesising the effects of positive and negative feedbacks between climate tipping elements.
Jonathan Donges, co-author
Ice sheets of particular importance
They find that interactions between the tipping elements overall tend to destabilise the network of tipping elements, even when substantial uncertainties in critical threshold temperatures, interaction strengths and interaction structure are taken into account.
The domino-like interactions foster cascading, nonlinear responses. “Under these circumstances, our model indicates that cascades are predominantly initiated by the polar ice sheets and mediated by the AMOC,” say the authors.
The results indicate that the ice sheets, which are already at risk of crossing their temperature thresholds within the Paris range of 1.5 to 2°C, are of particular importance for the stability of the climate system as a whole.
They also imply that the negative feedback loop connecting the Greenland Ice Sheet and the AMOC might not be able to stabilise the climate system as a whole, a possibility that was raised in earlier work by Gaucherel & Moron (2017).
“Our conceptual model does not represent the full complexity of the climate system, and is not intended to simulate the multitude of its biogeophysical processes or to make predictions of any kind,” say the authors.
“However, it does allow us to systematically assess the qualitative role of known interactions of some of the most critical components of the climate system in a comprehensive risk analysis”.
Overall, they conclude, this work can boost further investigation into the Earth’s tipping elements and how they interact.
In this study, four interacting tipping elements and their interactions are modelled using a complex networks approach. The four interacting tipping elements considered are the Greenland Ice Sheet, the West Antarctic Ice Sheet, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) and the Amazon rainforest.
Since more complex global climate models (such as general circulation models) are computationally prohibitively expensive for long-term simulations, the researchers condense the dynamics of each tipping element to a double-fold bifurcation equations approach. This differential equation leads to two stable states of each of the tipping elements dependent on the level of global warming and the interactions between the tipping elements.
The first stable represents present-day conditions (e.g. with an intact ice sheet on Greenland), and the second one represents the tipped state (e.g. without an ice sheet on Greenland). This means for instance that above a certain level of global warming, the current icesheet on Greenland would loose stability and would melt down, which could in turn lead to a slowdown of the AMOC via meltwater inflow in a cascading network interaction.
While the differential equations approach simplifies the nature of the tipping elements to some extent, it enables the researchers to integrate all relevant model uncertainties such as uncertainties in critical threshold temperatures, interaction strengths and interaction structure. For the propagation of these uncertainties, they employ a comprehensive Monte Carlo ensemble including more than 3.5 million simulations.
Wunderling, N., Donges, J.F., Kurths, J., Winkelmann, R. 2021. Interacting tipping elements increase risk of climate domino effects under global warming. Earth Syst. Dynam., 12, 601–619, 2021, https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-12-601-2021
Media coverage on the article by The Guardian
Research news | 2021-09-24
Increased use of AI can create new sustainability risks
Research identifies four areas where the use of AI-technologies can create challenges for both people and planet
Research news | 2021-09-23
Water resilient food systems for future climates
In a statement published by the Global Resilience Partnership, a group of 31 globally diverse practitioners and researchers, sound a clarion call for water resilience to be brought to the forefront of building resilient and sustainable food systems
Research news | 2021-09-23
New book on how culture and context affect transformative change
The book provides insights from researchers, activists, public servants, the private sector and others across five continents
Research news | 2021-09-23
Why designing policies for extreme events requires a system overview
While low-cost, rapid responses to extreme events are needed, proactive measures are more important
Research news | 2021-09-22
How can intersectionality contribute to social-ecological systems research?
Intersectionality is firmly making its way into research thinking. What does it offer sustainability scientists?
Research news | 2021-09-21
Three things needed for successful climate adaptation in cities
Freiburg, Durban and Singapore show why combining social, nature-based and technological solutions to urban climate challenges can work